Request a Demo

White Papers

Finding What Works in Learning: A Rubric for Analyzing Research Studies of Curricular Programs

September 01, 2016


There are educational research studies that tout amazing results. With the expanding number of print-based and digital curricula available, how do you understand the claims being made that a given program positively impacted learning? This paper by Dr. Tim Hudson helps you understand how to successfully review educational research and know how to thoroughly investigate the study, ask probing questions, and access the fine print about how a program “improves scores” or “doubles growth” using a clear rubric and three educational research examples, including a recent Center for Educational Policy Research at Harvard University study of DreamBox Learning Math.

Now you can get past educational hype and headlines with tools that help you understand how to critically examine curricular programs.

First, consider the underlying principles of the educational resource. An evaluation team should know how to assess whether or not a program is research-based and informed by principles published in educational and cognitive science research literature. For example, John Hattie’s meta-analysis in Visible Learning ranks Piagetian Programs as having one of the highest effect sizes and therefore one of the strongest impacts on learning.

Next, use a rigorous rubric. Critically analyze educational research studies to better understand the “fine print,” the implications of the study, and ultimately the potential of a program for improving student achievement in your classroom, school, or district, using a clear rubric. Dr. Hudson explains his rubric and then puts it into practice measuring three research studies by asking eight key questions.

Vice President of Learning

Dr. Tim Hudson

Dr. Tim Hudson is a learning innovator and education leader who frequently writes and speaks about the intersection of learning, schooling, and technology. At DreamBox, Dr. Hudson oversees the development of innovative learning experiences that engage students in mathematical thinking and provide teachers with useful information to support differentiation and personalization in their classrooms. He has spoken at national conferences such as ASCD, iNACOL, NCTM, and SXSWedu and along with DreamBox advisor Cathy Fosnot, co-authored the chapter “Classrooms Where Children Learn” in an NCTM book about Mathematics Intervention. Prior to joining DreamBox, Dr. Hudson spent more than 10 years working in public education, first as a High School Mathematics Teacher and then as a K–12 Mathematics Coordinator and Strategic Planning Facilitator for the Parkway School District in suburban St. Louis, MO. Follow his conversations on Twitter (@DocHudsonMath) and on the DreamBox Learning blog.

We're always talking

Subscribe & stay updated

Follow us for the latest

Related Resources


Tips to keep students learning during the holidays

DreamBox is a K–8 education solution whose mission is to transform the way students learn. Our lessons take children from wherever they are to where they want to be.

DreamBox is a K–8 education solution whose mission is to transform the way students learn. Our lessons take children from wherever they are to where they want to be.

For Administrators

OverviewThe Dreambox DifferenceDreamBox in Your DistrictCurriculum & Standards AlignmentProfessional DevelopmentAdministrator Resources
West Coast
777 108th Ave NE Suite 2300 Bellevue, WA 98004

Toll-free 1-877-451-7845

Download the DreamBox App

Elevate your DreamBox experience on iPad. With the DreamBox App, we’ve simplified your student learning experience.

© 2021 DreamBox.   Privacy    |   Legal |    Terms of Use   

“DreamBox” and the DreamBox logo are registered trademarks.   

All website design, content, text, graphics, the selection and arrangement thereof, and all software, including, but not limited to, the look and feel of the website, logos, designs, photographs, button icons, images, data compilations, and the software products, are the property of DreamBox Learning, Inc, its licensors, or its product suppliers, and is protected by the United States Copyright Act and international copyright laws. Copyright © 2021 DREAMBOX LEARNING, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.